Click the
back button to return to the publication.
Verdict highlighted
below
Docket as of March 14, 2002 Web PACER
U.S. District Court
U.S. District Court of Eastern Pennsylvania (Philadelphia)
CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 99-CV-2409
BIANCHI v. CITY OF PHILADELPHIA, et al
Filed: 05/11/99
Assigned to: JUDGE ANITA B. BRODY
Jury demand: Plaintiff
Demand: $0,000
Nature of Suit: 440
Lead Docket: None
Jurisdiction: Federal Question
Dkt# in other court: None
Cause: 42:1983 Civil Rights Act
ROBERT C. BIANCHI
ANDREW F. ERBA
PLAINTIFF [COR LD NTC]
WILLIAMS & CUKER
1617 JFK BLVD.
SUITE 800, ONE PENN CENTER
AT
SUBURBAN STATION
PHILA, PA 19103-2030
USA
TEL 215-557-0099
NANCY ABRAMS
[COR LD NTC]
SPECTOR GADON & ROSEN, P.C.
1635 MARKET STREET
SEVEN PENN CTR., 7th FLOOR
PHILADELPHIA, PA 19103
USA
TEL 215-241-8888
v.
CITY OF PHILADELPHIA
STEPHEN C. MILLER
DEFENDANT [COR LD NTC]
CITY OF PHILA.
LAW DEPT.
1515 ARCH STREET
17TH FLOOR
PHILA, PA 19102-1595
USA
TEL 215-683-5013
MICHAEL HOLMES, ESQ.
[COR LD NTC]
DEPUTY CITY SOLICITOR
1515 ARCH ST.
16th FLOOR
PHILA, PA 19102-1595
USA
TEL 215-686-5076
MILTON VELEZ
[COR LD NTC]
CITY OF PHILADELPHIA
LAW DEPARTMENT
1515 ARCH STREET
16th FLOOR
PHILADELPHIA, PA 19102-1595
USA
TEL 215-673-5077
. PHILA. FIRE DEPT.
DEFENDANT
[term 10/19/99]
PHILADELPHIA FIRE DEPARTMENT
MICHAEL HOLMES, ESQ.
DEFENDANT [term 01/07/02]
[term 01/07/02] [COR LD NTC]
DEPUTY CITY SOLICITOR
1515 ARCH ST.
16th FLOOR
PHILA, PA 19102-1595
USA
TEL 215-686-5076
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOCKET PROCEEDINGS
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DATE # DOCKET ENTRY
5/11/99 1 Complaint. filing fee $ 150 receipt #
700701 (aam)
[Entry
date 05/12/99]
5/11/99 -- Summons(es) issued; 2 originals mailed to:
Pro Se Plaintiff
5/12/99
(aam) [Entry date 05/12/99] [Edit date 05/12/99]
5/11/99 -- Demand for jury trial by PLAINTIFF
ROBERT C. BIANCHI (aam)
[Entry
date 05/12/99]
5/11/99 -- Standard Case Management Track. (aam)
[Entry date 05/12/99]
10/19/99 2 Appearance
of NANCY ABRAMS for PLAINTIFF ROBERT C. BIANCHI.
(fb)
[Entry date 10/19/99]
10/19/99 3 Amended
complaint by PLAINTIFF ROBERT C. BIANCHI. (fb)
[Entry
date 10/19/99]
10/19/99 -- 2 Original
Summons(es) issued. Mailed to counsel on
10/19/99.
(fb) [Entry date 10/19/99]
10/27/99 4 Affidavit
of: James Davis re: served summons and complaint
upon C.
Roberson on behalf of DEFENDANT PHILA. FIRE DEPT.
Served by:
Personal Service on 10/20/99. (mld)
[Entry
date 10/27/99]
10/27/99 5 Affidavit
of: Albert Brunozzi re: served summons and
complaint
upon Brenda Benson on behalf of DEFENDANT CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA. Served by: Personal Service on 10/21/99. (mld)
[Entry
date 10/27/99]
12/20/99 6 Answer to
Complaint by DEFENDANT CITY OF PHILADELPHIA,
DEFENDANT PHILA.
FIRE DEPT., (Attorney MICHAEL HOLMES),
with
affirmative defenses, Certificate of Service. (mld)
[Entry
date 12/21/99]
12/20/99 -- ISSUE
JOINED. (mld) [Entry date 12/21/99]
2/25/00 -- Pre-trial scheduling conference SET at
4:15 4/7/00 (mld)
[Entry
date 02/25/00]
4/4/00 7 ORDER THAT THE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE SET
FOR 4/7/00 IS
CANCELED
AND RESCHEDULED FOR 4/14/00 AT 4:15. (SIGNED BY
JUDGE
ANITA B. BRODY) 4/5/00 ENTERED AND COPIES MAILED AND
FAXED BY
CHAMBERS ON 4/4/00. (mld) [Entry date 04/05/00]
4/24/00 8 ORDER THAT ALL FACT DISCOVERY SHALL BE
COMPLETED BY
9/15/00 ;
ALL DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS DUE BY 10/5/00 ;
PLAINTIFF'S PRETRIAL MEMORANDUM
DUE 10/23/00 ; DEFENDANT'S
PRETRIAL
MEMORANDUM DUE 10/30/00 ; THIS CASE WILL BE PLACED
INTO THE
TRIAL POOL ON 11/6/00; THE PARTIES SHALL
SCHEDULE A
SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE BEFORE MAGISTRATE JUDGE
WELSH ON
OR ABOUT 9/1/00. (SIGNED BY JUDGE ANITA B. BRODY
) 4/24/00
ENTERED AND COPIES MAILED. (mld)
[Entry
date 04/24/00]
1/24/01 9 ORDER THAT THIS CASE IS LISTED FOR
TRIAL (AS A BACK-UP)
FOR
5/14/01 AT 9:30 ; A FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE WILL BE
HELD ON
5/11/01 AT 2:00 ; PLAINTIFF'S PRETRIAL SUBMISSIONS
DUE 4/9/01
; DEFENDANT'S PRETRIAL SUBMISSIONS DUE 4/16/01.
(SIGNED BY JUDGE ANITA B.
BRODY) 1/25/01 ENTERED AND
COPIES
MAILED. (mld) [Entry date 01/25/01]
4/4/01 10 JOINT MOTION by PLAINTIFF ROBERT C.
BIANCHI, DEFENDANT CITY
OF
PHILADELPHIA, DEFENDANT PHILA. FIRE DEPT. TO EXTEND
DEADLINES.
(np) [Entry date 04/05/01]
4/16/01 11 ORDER THAT THE PARTIES JOINT MOTION TO
EXTEND DEADLINES FOR
PRETRIAL
SUBMISSIONS IN THIS MATTER IS GRANTED. TRIAL,
CURRENTLY
SCHEDULED AS BACK-UP FOR 5/14/01, IS CONTINUED
UNTIL
FURTHER NOTICE. (SIGNED BY JUDGE ANITA B. BRODY)
4/16/01
ENTERED AND COPIES MAILED. (fb)
[Entry
date 04/16/01]
5/8/01 12 JOINT MOTION by DEFENDANT PHILADELPHIA
FIRE DEPARTMENT,
DEFENDANT
CITY OF PHILADELPHIA, PLAINTIFF ROBERT C. BIANCHI
FOR
EXTENSION OF PRETRIAL DEADLINES, CERTIFICATE OF
SERVICE.
(mbh) [Entry date 05/09/01]
5/8/01 13 Appearance of ANDREW ERBA for PLAINTIFF
ROBERT C. BIANCHI,
Certificate of Service. (mbh) [Entry date 05/09/01]
5/11/01 14 Withdrawal of appearance of Alan B.
Epstein for PLAINTIFF
ROBERT C.
BIANCHI, Certificate of Service. (rp)
[Entry
date 05/14/01]
5/18/01 15 ORDER THAT THE ABOVE CAPTIONED CASE WILL
COMMENCE TRIAL ON
7/9/01 AT
9:30 A.M. AS A BACK-UP TRIAL. THE FINAL PRETRIAL
CONFERENCE
WILL BE HELD ON 7/2/01 AT 10:30 A.M. IN
CHAMBERS.
PRETRIAL SUBMISSIONS ARE TO BE SUBMITTED AS
FOLLOWS:
ALL DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS ARE DUE BY 6/8/01. PARTIES
SHALL
DECIDE AND AGREE AMONG THEMSELVES UPON DATES FOR
SUMISSIONS
OF EXPERTS' REPORTS. PLAINTIFF'S PRETRIAL
MEMORANDUM
IS DUE BY 6/14/01. DEFENDANT'S PRETRIAL
MEMORANDUM
IS DUE BY 6/22/01. (SIGNED BY JUDGE ANITA B.
BRODY)
5/18/01 ENTERED AND COPIES MAILED. (fp)
[Entry
date 05/18/01]
6/5/01 16 ORDER THAT THE PARTIES' JOINT MOTION FOR
EXTENSION OF
PRETRIAL
DEADLINES IS DENIED AS MOOT (SIGNED BY JUDGE
ANITA B.
BRODY) 06/06/01 ENTERED AND COPIES MAILED. (mbh)
[Entry
date 06/06/01]
6/14/01 17 Plaintiff's Pretrial Memorandum,
Certificate of Service.
(jpd)
[Entry date 06/14/01]
6/15/01 18 ORDER THAT DEFTS' MOTION FOR EXTENSION
OF TIME IS GRANTED,
AND
COURT'S ORDER OF 5/18/01 IS VACATED; AND DISPOSITIVE
MOTIONS
SHALL BE FILED BY 6/22/01 ; AND RESPONSES TO
DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS SHALL BE FILED BY 7/9/01. (SIGNED BY
JUDGE
ANITA B. BRODY) 6/18/01 ENTERED AND COPIES MAILED.
(mld)
[Entry date 06/18/01]
6/15/01 -- MOTION by DEFENDANT PHILA. FIRE DEPT.,
DEFENDANT CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA FOR EXTENSION OF PRETRIAL DEADLINES,
CERTIFICATE
OF SERVICE. (See paper #18) (mld)
[Entry
date 06/18/01]
6/18/01 19 MOTION by PLAINTIFF ROBERT C. BIANCHI IN
LIMINE TO
PRECLUDE
PROPOSED EXPERT TESTIMONY, MEMORANDUM CERTIFICATE
OF SERVICE.
(jpd) [Entry date 06/18/01]
6/22/01 20 MOTION by DEFENDANT PHILA. FIRE DEPT.,
DEFENDANT CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE TEN PERSONS FROM
TESTIFYING, MEMORANDUM, CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE. (jpd)
[Entry date 06/25/01]
6/22/01 21 MOTION by DEFENDANT PHILA. FIRE DEPT.,
DEFENDANT CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, MEMORANDUM,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE. (jpd) [Entry date 06/25/01]
6/22/01 22 Pretrial Memorandum, by DEFENDANT PHILA.
FIRE DEPT.,
DEFENDANT
CITY OF PHILADELPHIA Certificate of Service. (jpd)
[Entry
date 06/25/01]
6/25/01 23 Appearance of MILTON VELEZ for DEFENDANT
CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA
, Certificate of Service. (rav)
[Entry
date 06/26/01]
7/5/01 24 ORDER THAT A CIVIL JURY TRIAL IS
SCHEDULED AS A BACK-UP
TRIAL TO
COMMENCE ON 10/15/01 AT 9:30. A FINAL PRETRIAL
CONFERENCE
WILL BE HELD ON 10/11/01 AT 10:30, IN CHAMBERS
(SIGNED BY
JUDGE ANITA B. BRODY) 7/5/01 ENTERED AND
COPIES
MAILED. (jl) [Entry date 07/05/01]
7/6/01 25 AMENDED ORDER THAT A CIVIL JURY TRIAL IS
SCHEDULED AS A
BACK-UP TRIAL TO COMMENCE ON
10/15/01 AT 9:30 A.M.. A
FINAL
PRETRIAL CONFERENCE WILL BE HELD ON 10/11/01 AT 10:30
A.M. IN
CHAMBERS, ROOM 7613 ON THE 7TH FLOOR. (SIGNED BY
JUDGE
ANITA B. BRODY), 7/6/01 ENTERED AND COPIES FAXED BY
CHAMBERS.
(rp) [Entry date 07/06/01]
7/10/01 26 Response by PLAINTIFF ROBERT C.
BIANCHI in opposition to
MOTION FOR
SUMMARY JUDGMENT, Certificate of Service. (ph)
[Entry
date 07/20/01]
7/10/01 27 MOTION by PLAINTIFF ROBERT C. BIANCHI TO
PERMIT FILING
PLAINTIFF'S OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY
JUDGMENT
AND APPENDIX IN SUPPORT OF THAT MOTION,
MEMORANDUM,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE. (ph)
[Entry
date 07/20/01]
7/12/01 28 Response by PLAINTIFF ROBERT C.
BIANCHI in opposition to
the
Defendant's motion to preclude witness, Memorandum,
Certificate of Service. (jl) [Entry date 07/12/01]
7/16/01 29 ORDER THAT THE PLAINTIFFS' TIME FOR
RESPONDING TO THE
DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT IS ENLARGED UNTIL
7/10/01.
THE PLAINTIFF SHALL FILE AND SERVE HIS RESPONSE TO
DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON OR BEFORE
7/10/01
(SIGNED BY JUDGE ANITA B. BRODY) 7/16/01 ENTERED
AND COPIES
MAILED. (jl) [Entry date 07/16/01]
7/19/01 30 Supplemental Memorandum by PLAINTIFF
ROBERT C. BIANCHI in
opposition
to DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT,
Memorandum, Certificate of Service. (jpd)
[Entry
date 07/19/01]
7/19/01 31 Reply by DEFENDANT PHILA. FIRE DEPT.,
DEFENDANT CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA to Plaintiff's
Memorandum in opposition to
Defendants' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, Certificate of
Service.
(afm) [Entry date 07/19/01]
8/3/01 32
Second Supplemental Memorandum by PLAINTIFF ROBERT C.
BIANCHI in
opposition to defendant's MOTION FOR SUMMARY
JUDGMENT,
Certificate of Service. (afm)
[Entry
date 08/03/01]
10/24/01 33 Supplemental
Pretrial Memorandum by ROBERT C. BIANCHI,
Certificate of Service. (afm) [Entry date 10/25/01]
12/13/01 34 MOTION by
DEFENDANT PHILA. FIRE DEPT., DEFENDANT CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA IN LIMINE, CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE. (afm)
[Entry
date 12/13/01]
12/17/01 35 Response
by PLAINTIFF ROBERT C. BIANCHI in opposition to
defendant's MOTION PRECLUDE WITNESSESS, MEMORANDUM,
Certificate of Service. (afm) [Entry date 12/18/01]
12/19/01 36 ORDER THAT
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO PERMIT FILING PLAINTIFF'S
OPPOSITION
TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND
APPENDIX
IN SUPPORT OF THAT MOTION IS GRANTED. (SIGNED BY
JUDGE ANITA
B. BRODY) 12/19/01 ENTERED AND COPIES MAILED .
(afm)
[Entry date 12/19/01]
1/7/02 37 MEMORANDUM AND ORDER THAT THE
PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT IS
DIMISSED
ON ALL COUNT AGAINST PHILADELPHIA FIRE DEPARTMENT.
THE MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT IS
GRANTED AS TO CERTAIN
DENIED AS
TO CERTAIN COUNTS. (SIGNED BY JUDGE ANITA B.
BRODY)
1/7/02 ENTERED AND COPIES MAILED. (afm)
[Entry
date 01/07/02] [Edit date 01/07/02]
1/10/02 38 ORDER THAT THE ABOVE CAPTIONED CASE WILL
BEGIN A CIVIL
JURY TRIAL
ON 2/11/02 AT 10:00 A.M. IN COURTROOM 7-B; FINAL
PRETRIAL
CONFERENCE WILL BE HELD ON 1/24/02 AT 2:00 P.M.,
ETC. (SIGNED
BY JUDGE ANITA B. BRODY) 1/10/02 ENTERED AND
COPIES
FAXED ON 1/9/02. (kw) [Entry date 01/10/02]
1/23/02 39 ORDER THAT THE FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE IS RESCHEDULED
AT 2:00 ON
1/28/02 (SIGNED BY JUDGE ANITA B. BRODY)
1/23/02
ENTERED. COPIES FAXED BY CHAMBERS 1/23/02. (afm)
[Entry
date 01/23/02]
1/24/02 40 Proposed Jury instructions by ROBERT C.
BIANCHI,
Certificate of Service. (afm) [Entry date 01/24/02]
1/24/02 41 Proposed Jury Interrogatories by ROBERT
C. BIANCHI
Certificate of Service. (afm) [Entry date 01/24/02]
1/25/02 42 ORDER THAT PLAINTIFF'S MOTION IN LIMINE
TO PRECLUDE
PROPOSED
EXPERT TESTIMONY IS DENIED WITHOUT PREJUDICE;
DEFENDANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE TEN PERSONS FROM
TESTIFYING
IS DENIED WITHOUT PREJUDICE. (SIGNED BY JUDGE
ANITA B.)
1/28/02 ENTERED AND COPIES MAILED. (afm)
[Entry date 01/28/02]
1/29/02 43 Appearance of STEPHEN C. MILLER for
DEFENDANT CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA, Certificate of Service. (afm)
[Entry
date 01/29/02]
1/30/02 44 MOTION by DEFENDANT CITY OF PHILADELPHIA
IN LIMINE TO
EXCLUDE
ALL EVIDENCE OF SEXUAL HARASSMENT, MEMORANDUM,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE. (afm) [Entry date 01/30/02]
1/30/02 45 Amended Pretrial Memorandum by CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA,
certificate of Service. (afm) [Entry date 01/30/02]
2/1/02 46 MOTION by DEFENDANT CITY OF PHILADELPHIA
IN LIMINE TO
PRECLUDE
THE PROPOSED WITNESS TESTIMONY OF JANET CAPANAA,
LLOYD
AIRS, LARRY SHELLENBER, NANCY ABRAMS, ESQ. ALAN
EPSTEIN, ESQ., JOSEPH CARDONA
ESQ., JOHN BOOTH, JAMES RIFFE
, KATRINA
NOTHERN AND MICHAEL BIEN, MEMORANDUM,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE. (afm) [Entry date 02/04/02]
2/4/02 47 MOTION by DEFENDANT CITY OF PHILADELPHIA
IN LIMINE TO
PRECLUDE
THE TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFF'S CO-WORKERS REGARDING
THEIR
ALLEGATIONS OF DISCRIMINATION, MEMORANDUM. (afm)
[Entry
date 02/04/02]
2/4/02 48 MOTION by DEFENDANT CITY OF PHILADELPHIA
TO BIFURCATE
TRIAL,
MEMORANDUM, CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE. (afm)
[Entry
date 02/04/02]
2/4/02 49 RENEWED MOTION by DEFENDANT CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA TO
DISCUSS PLAINTIFF'S
DUE PROCESS CLAIM , MEMORANDUM,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE. (afm) [Entry date 02/04/02]
2/4/02 50 Amended Pretrial Memorandum by ROBERT C.
BIANCHI,
Certificate of Service. (afm) [Entry date 02/05/02]
2/5/02 51 Minute entry re: Proceeding held 2/4/02,
Final Pretrial
Conference. (afm) [Entry date 02/05/02]
2/6/02 52 Proposed Jury instructions by CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA,
Certificate of Service. (afm) [Entry date 02/06/02]
2/6/02 53 Proposed Special Jury Interrogatories by
CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA, Certificate of Service. (afm)
[Entry
date 02/06/02]
2/6/02 54 Proposed Voir dire questions by
DEFENDANT CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA, Certificate of Service.
(afm)
[Entry
date 02/06/02]
2/6/02 55 Supplemental Pretrial Memorandum by
ROBERT C. BIANCHI,
Certificate of Service. (afm) [Entry date 02/06/02]
2/6/02 56 Proposed Jury instructions by CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA,
Certificate of Service. (afm) [Entry date 02/07/02]
2/6/02 57 Objections by DEFENDANT CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA to Plaintiff's
Proposed Jury
Instruction, Certificate of Service. (afm)
[Entry
date 02/07/02]
2/7/02 58 Requested Voir dire questions by
PLAINTIFF ROBERT C.
BIANCHI,
Certificate of Service. (afm) [Entry date 02/07/02]
2/7/02 59 Response by PLAINTIFF ROBERT C.
BIANCHI to defendant's
RENEWED
MOTION IN LIMINE SUR THE DUE PROCESS CLAIMS,
Certificate of Service. (afm) [Entry date 02/07/02]
2/8/02 60 MOTION by PLAINTIFF ROBERT C. BIANCHI IN
LIMINE TO EXCLUDE
INTRODUCTION OF THE DECISION OF THE UNEMPLOYMENT
COMPENSATION BOARD OF REVIEW, MEMORANDUM, CERTIFICATE OF
SERVICE.
(afm) [Entry date 02/08/02]
2/8/02 61 Objections by PLAINTIFF ROBERT C.
BIANCHI to defendant's
PROPOSED
JURY INSTRUCTIONS, Certificate of Service. (afm)
[Entry
date 02/11/02]
2/8/02 62 RENEWED MOTION by DEFENDANT CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA TO
DISMISS
PLAINTIFF'S DUE PROCESS CLAIM, CERTIFICATE OF
SERVICE.
(afm) [Entry date 02/11/02]
2/8/02 -- Reply by DEFENDANT CITY OF PHILADELPHIA
to plaintiff's
response
to defendant's MOTION TO DISMISS THE DUE PROCESS
CLAIM.
(see paper #62) (afm) [Entry date 02/11/02]
2/11/02 63 Reply by DEFENDANT CITY OF PHILADELPHIA
to plaintiff's
MONELL
ARGUMENT, Certificate of Service. (afm)
[Entry
date 02/11/02]
2/12/02 64 Minute entry: 2/11/02, Voir Dire/ civil
jury trial day #1.
10 jurors
selected to the jury box. The court instructs the
jury.
Opening statement by plaintiff and defendant. Robert
Bianchi
was called and sworn. (jl) [Entry date 02/12/02]
2/13/02 65 Minute entry re: Proceeding held
2/12/02, plaintiff's
unopposed
motion to sequester witnesses is granted. (afm)
[Entry
date 02/13/02]
2/14/02 66 Proposed Supplemental Jury instructions
by CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA, Certificate of Service. (jl)
[Entry
date 02/14/02]
2/15/02 67 Minute entry re: Proceeding held
2/13/02. (afm)
[Entry
date 02/15/02]
2/19/02 68 Minute entry re: Proceeding held
2/14/02. (afm)
[Entry
date 02/19/02]
2/19/02 69 Minute entry re: Proceeding held
2/15/02. (afm)
[Entry
date 02/19/02]
2/20/02 70 ORDER THAT THE CLERK OF COURT FOR THE
EASTERN DISTRICT OF
PA BE AND
HE IS HEREBY DIRECTED TO FURNISH LUNCH FOR JURORS
AND ONE
DEPUTY CLERK ENGAGED IN THE ABOVE ENTITLED CASE.
(afm)
[Entry date 02/20/02]
2/20/02 71 Questions to jurors and answers thereof.
(afm)
[Entry
date 02/21/02]
2/20/02 72 Minute entry re: Proceeding held
2/19/02. (afm)
[Entry
date 02/21/02]
2/20/02 73 ORDER THAT THE ATTACHED JURY QUESTION #1
IS MADE PART OF
THE
RECORD. (SIGNED BY JUDGE ANITA B. BRODY) 2/21/02
ENTERED
AND COPIES MAILED. (afm) [Entry date 02/21/02]
2/27/02 74 Bill of costs by PLAINTIFF ROBERT C.
BIANCHI, Certificate
of
Service. (fb) [Entry date 02/28/02]
2/27/02 75 MOTION BY PLAINTIFF ROBERT C. BIANCHI IN
SUPPORT OF
REQUEST
FOR ATTORNEY FEES AND LITIGATION COSTS, APPENDIX,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE. (fb) [Entry date 02/28/02]
2/28/02 76 Declaration of Alice W. Ballard in support of plff's
petition
for an award of attorney's fees. (kw)
[Entry
date 02/28/02]
2/28/02 77 MOTION by PLAINTIFF ROBERT C. BIANCHI TO
ADD ADDITIONAL
VERIFICATIONS
IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR ATTORNEY
FEES,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE. (jl) [Entry date 02/28/02]
3/5/02 78
CIVIL JUDGMENT ORDER THAT JUDGMENT IS ENTERED IN FAVOR OF
ROBERT C. BIANCHI AND AGAINST CITY OF PHILADELPHIA
for
$1,237,500.00. 3/6/02 ENTERED AND COPIES MAILED.
(SIGNED
BY JUDGE ANITA B. BRODY) (afm) [Entry date
03/06/02]
3/5/02 79 Joint Stipulation to stay defendant's
response and
consideration
of questions of attorney's fees and bill of
cost until
after resolution of defendant's post trial
motion,
Certificate of Service. (afm) [Entry date 03/06/02]
3/5/02 -- Case closed (kv) [Entry date 03/11/02]
3/11/02 80 Transcript for Proceeding held 2/11/02 (afm)
[Entry
date 03/12/02]
3/11/02 81 Transcript for Proceeding held 2/12/02 (afm)
[Entry
date 03/12/02]
3/11/02 82 Transcript for Proceeding/Jury Trial held 2/13/02 (afm)
[Entry
date 03/12/02]
3/11/02 83 Transcript for Proceeding/Hearning held 2/19/02 (afm)
[Entry
date 03/12/02]
3/12/02 84 Transcript of 2/14/02, trial (jl) [Entry
date 03/12/02]
3/12/02 85 Transcript of 2/15/02, jury trial (jl)
[Entry date 03/12/02]
3/14/02 86 Transcript of 2/4/02, Final Pretrial
Conference (jl)
[Entry
date 03/14/02]
3/14/02 87 MOTION by DEFENDANT CITY OF PHILADELPHIA
FOR JUDGMENT NOT
WITHSTANDING THE VERDICT, OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE FOR NEW
TRIAL,
MEMORANDUM, CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE. (afm)
[Entry
date 03/14/02]
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
END OF DOCKET: 2:99cv2409
Click the back button to return to the publication.